SpaceMed Newsletter

Healthcare Facility Planning Tools and Guidelines

Volume 4, Number 3

 

Fall 2011

 

 

 

In This Issue

 

 

 

 

SpaceMed Home

About the Author

Prioritizing Healthcare Facility Projects

Use of Interactive Technology Boosts Inpatient Satisfaction  

Hospital Capital Spending is Taking on New Focus 

Radiology Becoming Untethered

Operating Room Size Guidelines

Feature                                                                                            Print (PDF)

 

Prioritizing Healthcare Facility Projects                                                       

BACKGROUND

The rationale for specific renovation, expansion, or new construction projects undertaken by healthcare organizations may not always appear logical or to be a prudent use of limited capital dollars. Most hospital leaders, care providers, facility planners, and architects can cite an example of a misguided project ― almost always by some other organization or under the direction of someone else. Historically there was often a focus on a “project” being on-time and on-budget without enough scrutiny as to whether it is the right project in the first place. Today, most healthcare organizations have many more demands for facility upgrading and expansion than available dollars ― particularly when bricks and mortar projects compete with investments in new medical equipment and information technology and with lenders providing their own scrutiny. 

DEVELOPING A RATIONAL APPROACH 

Healthcare leaders may consider a number of factors to reach consensus on which projects ultimately get funded and the sequence of their funding compared to other capital expenditures. At a minimum, the rationale for each potential project should be evaluated based on the following factors:

  • Mitigate risk/health safety. Facility issues related to building code deficiencies, patient safety, and/or compliance with other regulatory requirements are usually the highest priority as funding decisions are being made.

  • Enhance operational efficiency. The ability of a specific project to deliver an immediate return on investment such as a reduction in labor costs or minimizing investments in new medical equipment and instrumentation will be viewed positively by potential lenders.

  • Improve space utilization. A one-time capital investment to consolidate space or improve the utilization of existing space (thus increasing capacity) will reduce the associated costs for housekeeping, maintenance, utilities, and other ongoing facility-related costs.

  • Improve patient access/satisfaction. Depending on the market dynamics and competition from other community providers, and the organizations mission, improving patient access and customer satisfaction can result in additional market share (and revenue).

  • Build future capacity. This may be an appropriate rationale for a project in a growing market or where another competitor could potentially go out of business ― resulting in an opportunity to increase market share.

  • Renew/retool physical plant. Every business ― whether a hospital or any other industry ― must routinely invest in their physical plant to stay competitive as their patient care delivery model evolves due to changes in medical practice, reimbursement, regulations, technology, and customer preferences.

  • Facilitate donor/partner funding. A project may quickly become a high priority when there is a donor ready and willing to fund all or part of a specific project. At the same time, a partner may be identified who can share in the funding (and more importantly ― in the ongoing operational costs).

The matrix below provides an example used by a senior leadership team to summarize their high priority projects and the corresponding rationale for each. Cells with an “X” indicate the potential rationale for a specific project on the list. It should be noted that each healthcare organization will have unique rationale relative to any given project.

 

Once consensus has been reached on the rational for each project, specific projects may also be grouped and sequenced based on:

  • Urgency (e.g., response to a competitive threat, code issues, revenue generation)

  • Renovation/construction feasibility and cost-effectiveness (e.g., sequencing of tasks)

  • Available capital at different points in time

  • Bandwidth of the organization to handle multiple ongoing projects

back to top

Cynthia Hayward, AIA, ACHA, FAAHC

Principal

Hayward & Associates LLC

chayward@hayward-assoc.com

In the News

 

Use of Interactive Technology Boosts Inpatient Satisfaction

Hospitals within six healthcare systems saw dramatic increases in their patient satisfaction scores when using interactive monitors that allow patients to access information about their care and to communicate with staff. The hospitals provided patients with in-room monitors that allowed them to ask clinicians questions about their care, inquire about food menus, request help with minor tasks, read about their medical condition, and access their post-discharge instructions. Satisfaction with educational materials increased by 42 percent and overall patient satisfaction scores increased by at least 10 percent.

The healthcare systems included El Paso Children's Hospital (El Paso TX), Palisades Medical Centre (North Bergen NJ), and University Hospitals Seidman Cancer Center (Cleveland OH).

Source: Fierce Healthcare (www.fiercehealthcare.com)  back to top

Trendline                                                                                              Print (PDF)

Hospital Capital Spending is Taking on New Focus

BACKGROUND

Hospital capital spending was slowing down even before the financial meltdown in 2008 as hospitals began shifting their capital funds toward shoring up infrastructure and cutting back on capital spending, overall. The economic downturn makes it increasingly more difficult and expensive for hospitals to finance capital expenditures. Interest and lease rates have risen and the availability of debt is becoming more restricted as lenders seek to avoid risk.

CURRENT TREND

Capital remains elusive as most non-profit hospitals in the U.S. find it difficult to access capital. Credit rating agencies want to see evidence of:

  • A physician alignment strategy

  • Clinical integration and cost reduction actions

  • An information technology (IT) plan

  • Strategic plans focused on capturing more market share

IMPACT ON CONSTRUCTION

When it comes to construction, the focus is on fast returns. Construction projects are being scaled down with resources being directed to:

  • Compliance with regulatory requirements

  • Enhancing throughput

  • Improving the quality of patient care and patient outcomes

  • Capturing additional market share

  • Information technology

Additionally, construction projects which generate superior returns are favored ― such as surgical services and procedures. Improving access and throughput is a priority such as improving turnaround times in the emergency department or building freestanding urgent care centers to reduce hospital emergency department visits.

Capital spending on information technology is becoming even more pervasive as it underpins a provider’s ability to shift to new care models ― including efforts to implement an ambulatory electronic medical record (EMR) ― assuming that an inpatient EMR and computerized physician order entry system have already been implemented along with e-scheduling, physician e-prescribing, picture archiving and communication system (PACS), and results reporting components.  back to top

Cynthia Hayward, AIA, ACHA, FAAHC

Principal

Hayward & Associates LLC

chayward@hayward-assoc.com

Technology

 

Radiology Becoming Untethered

Healthcare imaging has come a long way from the days of plastic film, wet processing, and long waits for results. Digital radiography ― wired or wireless ― offers faster results and better imaging quality. Wireless devices take this convenience and efficiency one step further. According to the director of radiology at a large Midwest hospital which uses two Siemens Ysio wireless radiograph machines "We can take the imaging plate and put it on the floor, under the bed, and under the patient, or we can put it on a stool and let the patient put their leg or arm up on it." Getting rid of the wires and cords dragging across the floor not only improves safety but eliminates another source of infection. Although there are several wireless and portable radiography machines on the market, the technology is not yet widespread. Canon began touting its first wireless digital radiography system in 2010. MinXray also launched a portable system that is also designed to be used in the field such as during disaster response. These devices will probably get more traction with the advent of the fourth generation (4G) wireless network from cellular wireless companies which will enable radiologists to upload and download images much faster than they have been able to in the past ― at least for preliminary reads and sharing images with patients and family members on smart phones, iPads, and similar devices.  back to top

Rule-of-Thumb

 

Operating Room Size Guidelines

According to the American College of Surgeons, the size and location of the surgical procedure rooms should be determined by the level of care to be provided. Three levels of care are identified for operating rooms (ORs) as follows:

Class A provides for minor surgical procedures performed under topical, local, or regional anesthesia without pre-operative sedation.

Class B provides for minor or major surgical procedures performed in conjunction with oral, parenteral, or intravenous sedation or under analgesic or dissociative drugs.

Class C provided for major surgical procedures that require general or regional block anesthesia and support of vital bodily functions.

As shown below, the amount of clear floor area and minimum clear dimension also depend on the type of surgical intervention and the corresponding size and amount of equipment needed and the number of people on the surgical team. It is also to be expected that achieving the ideal operating room size may not be possible when an older facility is undergoing renovation. General guidelines for various types of operating rooms are included below:

 

Type of

Operating Room

Minimum

Clear Floor Area (NSF)

Minimum

Clear Dimension (Feet)

Comments

       

General Operating Room

400 NSF

20 Feet

Provides for minor or major surgical procedures performed in conjunction with oral, parenteral, or intravenous sedation or under analgesic or dissociative drugs or where general or regional block anesthesia is used and vital bodily functions supported (Class C).

For renovations, a minimum of 360 NSF of clear floor area should be achieved with a minimum clear dimension of 18 feet.

Specialty Operating Room

600 NSF

20 Feet

Provides for major surgical procedures that require large equipment and/or additional personnel ― such as cardio-vascular, orthopedic, and neurological procedures.

For renovations, a minimum of 360 NSF of clear floor area should be achieved for orthopedic surgery with a minimum clear dimension of 18 feet. Operating rooms for cardiovascular, neurological, and other special procedures should have a minimum clear floor area of 400 NSF.

Cystoscopic and Endo-urologic Procedure Room

350 NSF

15 Feet

Provides for surgical cystoscopy and minimally-invasive endo-urologic procedures. 

For renovations, a minimum of 250 NSF of clear floor area should be achieved.

Minor Outpatient Surgery Room

250 NSF

15 Feet

Provides for surgery and other procedures that require moderate sedation (Class B).

Minor Outpatient Procedure Room

150 NSF

12 Feet

Provides for surgical and other procedures that require minimal sedation (Class A).

       

Note: NSF represents the net square feet or inside wall-to-wall dimensions (or clear floor area in the above table) of an individual room.

Source: Guidelines for Design and Construction of Health Care Facilities ― The Facility Guidelines Institute. Washington, DC. 2010 Edition.

Rule 1311.4.3

back to top

www.spacemed.com

Copyright ©2011 SpaceMed. All rights reserved.